How to Hire a Private Investigator: Step-by-Step
Hiring a private investigator is a significant decision. This guide walks you through every step - from knowing when you need one to evaluating candidates, asking the right questions, and getting the best results.
Step 1: Determine If You Need a Private Investigator
Not every situation requires a PI. Consider hiring one when:
- You need evidence that will hold up in court
- Your own research has reached a dead end
- The situation involves potential legal liability if mishandled
- You need surveillance, which is difficult and risky to do yourself
- You need someone with database access and investigative tools
- Confidentiality is critical and you cannot involve friends or family
If your situation matches any of these, a licensed private investigator is the right choice.
Step 2: Verify Licensing and Credentials
This is the single most important step. An unlicensed investigator can produce inadmissible evidence, create legal liability for you, and waste your money. Always:
- Ask for the PI's license number and issuing state
- Verify the license through your state regulatory board
- Confirm the license is current and in good standing
- Ask about professional liability insurance
- Check for any disciplinary actions on record
Step 3: Evaluate Experience and Specialization
Not all PIs handle all types of cases equally well. Ask about their specific experience with your type of case:
- Infidelity cases - Look for extensive surveillance experience and sensitivity
- Child custody - Seek investigators experienced with family court requirements
- Corporate investigations - Look for business investigation background and corporate experience
- Asset searches - Choose investigators with financial research expertise
Step 4: Ask the Right Questions
During your initial consultation, ask these questions:
- Are you licensed in the state where this investigation will take place
- How many years have you been a licensed investigator
- Do you carry professional liability insurance
- What is your experience with cases like mine
- What is your fee structure (Hourly, flat fee, retainer)
- What deliverables will I receive (Reports, photos, video)
- How will you communicate updates during the investigation
- What is your estimated timeline and total cost
- Can you provide professional references
- What happens if you do not find what I am looking for
Step 5: Understand the Fee Structure
Before signing any agreement, make sure you understand exactly how you will be billed. Read our complete private investigator cost guide for detailed pricing information.
Step 6: Review the Service Agreement
A professional PI will always provide a written service agreement. Review it carefully for scope, deliverables, fees, confidentiality, and termination terms. Never hire a PI who refuses to provide a written contract.
Step 7: Know What to Expect During the Investigation
Once the investigation begins:
- You should receive regular progress updates at agreed intervals
- Do not conduct your own parallel surveillance - this can compromise the professional investigation
- Be honest with your investigator about all relevant information
- Respect the investigator's professional judgment on methodology and timing
- Keep the investigation confidential to avoid tipping off the subject
Red Flags to Avoid
- Cannot or will not provide a license number
- Promises specific results or outcomes
- Offers services that seem illegal (hacking, wiretapping, trespassing)
- Refuses to provide a written agreement
- Demands large payments with no accounting
- Has no verifiable online presence or reviews
- Pressures you to commit immediately
Understanding what a PI can legally do helps you identify illegitimate operators.
Hiring a PI - FAQ
Start with a brief, non-sensitive inquiry. A reputable investigator should listen, assess your needs, explain lawful options, verify licensing, and provide a written cost estimate before any commitment.
Ask the investigator for their license number and issuing state. Then verify it through the state regulatory board or licensing authority. Most states have online verification databases. Our guide on PI licensing by state provides links for each state.
Key questions: Are you licensed How many years of experience do you have Do you carry liability insurance What is your fee structure Can you provide references Have you handled cases like mine What deliverables will I receive How will you communicate updates
For surveillance and fieldwork, local knowledge is valuable. For background checks and research, location matters less. National firms with local investigator networks offer the best of both - local field expertise with national resources and coordination capabilities.
A proper service agreement should include: scope of investigation, estimated timeline, fee structure, payment terms, confidentiality provisions, reporting expectations, communication protocols, and termination conditions. Never hire a PI without a written agreement.
Most agencies can begin within 24-48 hours for urgent cases. Standard cases typically start within a few business days after the service agreement is signed and retainer is received. Discuss your timeline during the initial consultation.
Ready to Evaluate a PI
Send an email inquiry with your state, case type, deadline, and the questions you need answered before hiring.
Private inquiry - No obligation - Email only